« Huge Relief: Obama's Awesomely Awesome Charm Means Anti-Americanism Isn't A Problem Any More | Main | Obama's Anti-Israel Posture Undermining The Peace Process, Hardening Palestinian Demands »

One Jerusalem Conference Call With George Gilder: Israel Is The "Crucial Battlefield For Capitalism In The World"

Battlefield

This morning's One Jerusalem conference call was with George Gilder, the Reaganomics revolutionary who's now a capitalism and technology guru. His new book is the The Israel Test. The book's argument is two-fold, per a couple of Gilder's lines from the conference call: "Israel's technologies lead the world today" and Israel is hated precisely because "what Israel does is the best in the world." Israel is despised not because of where it supposedly fails - human rights violations, occupation, etc - but because of where it's most successful - capitalism. The left's blind and irrational anti-Israel fanaticism is driven by pure, old fashioned resentment.

The audio from the call should be on the One Jerusalem frontpage soon enough. You should at least take 5 minutes to listen to Gilder's synopsis of the book - clear, concise, powerful. In the meantime other bloggers from the call - Carl from Israel Matzav, Clyde Middleton from Patriotroom.com, and Rick Richman from Jewish Current Issues - will probably also post their thoughts.

Gilder's Israel Test has a relatively precise definition:

The [Israel] test can be summarized by a few questions: What is your attitude toward people who excel you in the creation of wealth or in other accomplishments? Do you aspire to their excellence or do you seethe at it? Do you admire and celebrate exceptional achievement or do you impugn it and seek to tear it down?

In a lot of ways the book takes Gilder's old argument that anti-capitalism emerges out of old-fashioned vulgar resentment and applies it to the contemporary Middle East. That a lot of anti-capitalism is tied up in ugly envy is pretty straightforward. You can see it in the eyeroll-inducing schadenfreude that erupted across Europe last year:

The spectacle of highly paid American bankers falling on their faces inspired smug lectures from afar about the reckless pursuit of profits, disdain for regulation, and manic risk-taking that characterize U.S.-style capitalism. The tsk-tsk-ing reached a new level with a cover story in the German newsweekly Der Spiegel, "The End of Arrogance": "The banking crisis is upending American dominance of the financial markets and world politics." The piece notes the delicious irony of the United States having to nationalize parts of its financial system. "The Americans are now paying the price for their pride," it notes. "Gone are the days when the U.S. could go into debt with abandon." Gone, too, are the days of "turbo-capitalism" imposing its mores of "avarice and greed" on the global economy.

It's a vicious cycle. Hatred of Israel, a shining jewel of the free market, fuels anti-capitalism. Anti-capitalism, which gives the Jewish State breathing room to excel, fuels anti-Semitic resentment.

Gilder's anti-capitalist resentment thesis has not a little bit of explanatory force. It's not an accident that so many anti-Israel academics are also socialists or that so many socialist rags are fiercely and explicitly pro-Hamas (cached link). The dual loathing has a long history: when he was describing the contours of National Socialism, Hitler specifically targeted his anti-Jewish tirades at bankers, industrialists, and innovators.

It's also not an accident that anti-Israel policies take an anti-free market form. That's exactly what you'd expect if anti-Israel antipathy develops precisely to the degree that the Jewish State maintains a prosperous free market. When Israel was in charge of Gaza and the West Bank those areas were among of the world's fastest growing economies. Incomes tripled. Palestinian life expectancy increased from 42 years to 70 years.

But instead of letting Israel build more universities, hospitals, and electricity plants, the international community hijacked the economies of the territories and began pouring in aid. The result: a feverish swamp of seething hatred, conspiracism, and murder.

There is a direct correlation between homicide and donor aid in the territories. It is undeniable that Palestinians use security assistance to murder Israeli civilians. And of course the UN-operated schools and community centers are used to brainwash children into fanatics. Whoever in the Obama administration thought it was a good idea to pour more than a billion dollars into Gaza needs to read Gilder's book.

The point isn't that Israel should be celebrated simply for being the world's #1 per capita tech producer, although maybe people should consider that. And it's not even that regional solutions are hampered because the left's anti-capitalist sensibilities give rise to anti-Israel fantasies, both of which undermine clear analysis. It's that the West relies heavily on Israel for innovation and progress, and so it's in the objective national interest of Western countries to stop demonizing Israeli citizens and Israeli accomplishments. Of course if those countries are already against innovation and progress that's a much tougher case to make.

References:
* The Israel Test [George Gilder / Amazon.com]
* Guest Columnist: The Israel Test [JPost]
* People Who Live in Glass Häuser [Slate]
* Simple Equation - More Aid To Palestinians Means More Murders A Year Later [MR]
* Hamas: Yup, We're Still Using US-Supplied Weapons To Kill Israelis [MR]
* Adorable! Palestinian Kindergarteners Graduate, Do "Victory Dance" Around IDF Bodies. [MR]
* Savages: Hamas Broadcasts Cartoon Mocking Shalit (UPDATED And BUMPED: Obama Wants Another $400m Next Year, Full Text Of Waxman Email Added) [MR]

Previously:
* OneJerusalem.org Conference Call: Rep. Eric Cantor (R, VA-7) On HR 756, Condemning the Wakf's Destruction Of The Temple-Mount
* One Jerusalem Conference Call: Former Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
* OneJerusalem.org Conference Call: Pastor John Hagee, Senior Pastor of Cornerstone Church [FAQ: Debunking Liberal Myths About Evangelical Support For Israel]

TrackBacks

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.mererhetoric.com/mt/mr-trackbacks2008.cgi/1713

Follow / Support Mere Rhetoric


Our Sponsors

About

  • Omri Ceren is a PhD candidate studying Rhetoric at the University of Southern California's Annenberg School for Communication. He lives in downtown Los Angeles.

    Email: omri@mererhetoric.com

    AIM: mererhetoricblog
    ICQ: 342854935
    gTalk: mererhetoricblog@gmail.com
    Y!: mererhetoricblog
    MSN: mererhetoricblog@hotmail.com

News Informer

One Jerusalem Radio

Search




Approbation

  • JIB 2007 Finalist

    Large Blog | Pro Israel Blog | News Blog | Right Wing Blog | News Post | Right Wing Post | Overall Post | Series of Posts | Specialty Contribution


    • The best blog going -- Larry Greenfield, Claremont Institute Fellow

    • One of the best blogs in the known universe -- Robert Avrech, Seraphic Secret

    • A must read... the new shining star of the Blogosphere -- Alexandra von Maltzan, All Things Beautiful

    • I read Omri and... you should too -- Meryl Yourish, Yourish.com

    • So damned good, it makes me want to pack up and leave the 'sphere -- Elder of Ziyon

    • Only Omri... could write a sentence like this -- Lynn B, In Context

    • Gets the gold star -- Anne Lieberman, Boker Tov, Boulder!

    • Stellar analysis -- Rick Richman, Jewish Current Issues

      Premio Apache Badge

    Disapprobation

    • [IsraPundit's] token fascist -- anonymous Democratic official
    • A clearly radical blogger based in Southern California -- Brown Daily Herald

    Powered By

    Hosting Matters
    Movable Type
    Google Analytics Tracker